| Bacon | Bacon allows for same gender breedings. Must be used with a breeding potion. | Adventure Item |
| Breeding Potion | This purple potion is basic item needed for breeding two Otay Corral Critters | Non-Adventure Item |
| Female Potion | This potion will ensure that the offspring will be female | Non-Adventure Item |
| Frankenstien Bag | Can contain breeding items, custom vouchers, random premades, etc. Only available during | Non-Adventure Item |
| Full Custom Scroll | This scroll is good for one Full Custom Critter from the Otay Corral | Adventure Item |
| Green Potion | The offspring will look more like the father | Non-Adventure Item |
| Male Potion | This potion insures the offspring will be male. | Non-Adventure Item |
| Naming Charm | Give this charm to your Otay Corral Critter so they remember their name | Non-Adventure Item |
| Orange Potion | The offspring will look more like the mother | Non-Adventure Item |
| Pumpkin Bag | Can contain breeding items, custom vouchers, random premades, etc. Only available during | Non-Adventure Item |
| Treat Bag | Can contain breeding items, custom vouchers, random premades, etc. Only available during special events. | Non-Adventure Item |
| Twin Potion | This potion allows for twins when used with a breeding potion. 50/50 chance of identical or fraternal twins | Adventure Item |
| Vampie Bag | Can contain breeding items, custom vouchers, random premades, etc. Only available during Halloween. | Non-Adventure Item |